The whole question is as follows: "So, are we here to include good RP'ers, and help make them great? Or are we a bunch of elitist fucks who ignore decent RP'ers just because they're playing something we personally wouldn't?"

The answer is this simple: We are here to include RP'ers and help make them great.  Even in our mission statement it says: "...we do not at all believe ourselves superior."  You know.  I really don't care what your personal opinion is of a player and/or his/her character.  I've been guilty of making fun of people myself for their Mary Sue characters and carbon copy storylines.  But seriously.  You don't win any favors by being like me and being impolite and making fun of everybody.  Some people are deserving of a chance, and if other people are giving them chances then don't be a prick and go stepping all over their toes for trying to be nice.